Are We Missing Something? Why Indian Markets Are Lagging Behind the S&P 500

07.08.25 11:21:10

The S&P 500 has been on an unstoppable run lately—posting new highs almost every other week. It’s been a stellar ride for US equities, driven largely by tech giants and AI euphoria.

Meanwhile, back home in India, the Nifty 50 seems to be treading water.

Despite strong economic fundamentals, it still hasn’t crossed the peak it touched way back in September 2024. That’s nearly 10 months of sideways or downward movement—an underperformance that feels out of sync with the broader India growth narrative.

And the divergence runs deeper.

Over 60% of NSE 500 stocks are currently trading well below their 2024 highs. That’s a wide breadth of weakness across sectors—not just isolated to a few companies or industries.

So, what’s going on?

Global Fireworks vs. Local Fog?

On the surface, the comparison is puzzling:

  • The US economy is grappling with major headwinds—soaring debt, sticky inflation, global tariff tensions, and severe political polarisation with Trump 2.0 on the horizon.

  • India, on the other hand, boasts strong demographics, robust domestic flows, and a resilient consumption story.

In fact, India's long-term structural trends—especially in sectors like financial services, infrastructure, and digital transformation—remain firmly intact.

And yet, the market momentum tells a different story.


Possible Explanations: Reading Between the Lines

Could this be a case of the market pricing in something we’re not seeing clearly yet?

Here are a few possibilities worth considering:

  • Is the market underestimating a Trump 2.0 presidency? Could there be a new economic framework or AI-centric strategy in the US that’s quietly inspiring confidence?

  • Has the emerging market narrative been sidelined? Global capital might be chasing high-conviction opportunities in the US, especially in AI and Big Tech, while overlooking EMs temporarily.

  • Are we early, not wrong?
    Long-term investors often find themselves ahead of the curve. Perhaps the data-driven investors are still building positions, and we’re just not seeing the breakout yet.

  • Is this poker, not chess?
    Markets don’t always play by the rules of logic. Sometimes strength is disguised as weakness—and vice versa.


India’s Structural Story Still Holds

At Hedge Equities, we continue to believe in India’s long-term wealth creation story.

Through our portfolio management services, we help investors navigate short-term noise while staying anchored to long-term goals. Whether you're rebalancing your investment portfolio or looking to diversify into mutual funds, equities, or insurance-linked products, our advisors ensure your strategy is aligned with the bigger picture.


Final Thoughts

Is the market signaling something deeper—or is it simply reflecting short-term sentiment while the long-term engine revs up quietly in the background?

We don’t claim to have all the answers. But we do know that staying invested, diversified, and informed has always paid off over the long term.

So, are we missing something—or are we just early?

We’d love to hear your thoughts.